Farm to Table Directory

Home › Guides › Seasonal Cooking & Recipes › Recipes That Showcase Heirloom Tomatoes

Seasonal Cooking & Recipes

Recipes That Showcase Heirloom Tomatoes

A true heirloom tomato in August is the reason many of us cook seasonally. Heirlooms are open-pollinated varieties, passed down for generations, valued for flavor, color and shape over shipping durability. They are thin-skinned, irregular, sometimes cracked and wildly good. Because they are fragile and expensive, they deserve recipes that respect them: raw, barely cooked or cooked in ways that preserve their character. This article covers how to choose, store and cut heirlooms, then offers recipes with measurements and methods, and explains when to use ordinary tomatoes instead for cooked dishes where heirloom nuance would be lost.

What Makes a Tomato an Heirloom

An heirloom is generally an open-pollinated variety that has been grown and saved for decades, though definitions vary by seed company and region. The seeds breed true, so saved seed produces similar plants. Names like Brandywine, Cherokee Purple, Green Zebra and Mortgage Lifter are widely grown, while countless local varieties exist.

Heirlooms differ in flavor from sweet and low-acid to tart and complex. Color ranges from pink, red and orange to yellow, green, purple and striped. Thin skin and high moisture make them poor travelers, which is why the best ones are found at farmers markets and farm stands. Learn more about why these varieties matter in The Importance of Heritage Breeds and Seeds.

Choosing and Storing

Buy heirlooms ripe or nearly so. Smell the stem end: it should smell sweet and tomatoey. The fruit should feel heavy for its size and yield slightly to gentle pressure. Cracks around the shoulder and uneven shape are normal, but avoid mold or weeping soft spots. Green varieties stay green when ripe, so judge by give and aroma.

Store on the counter, stem side down, out of direct sun, and eat within a few days. Refrigeration damages flavor and texture, though a fully ripe tomato that you cannot use can go in the fridge for a day or two; bring it to room temperature before eating. For very ripe seconds, cook them into sauce. See Selecting the Right Produce for Your Kitchen for general choosing tips.

Cutting and Salting

Use a sharp serrated knife or a very sharp chef's knife, so you slice rather than crush. Cut large tomatoes into thick slices or wedges, small ones in halves. Salting matters: sprinkle flaky salt on cut tomatoes and wait 5 to 10 minutes. The salt draws out juice and amplifies flavor. Use a good olive oil afterward, and a splash of vinegar only if the tomato is not acidic.

Mix colors on a platter for visual interest, and add a variety of sizes. Serve at room temperature. Cold mutes the aroma. For cooking, core the stem and score the base if you are peeling.

Recipe 1: The Classic Plate

Ingredients for four: 2 pounds (900 g) mixed heirloom tomatoes, 1/2 teaspoon flaky salt, 3 tablespoons good olive oil, 1 teaspoon red wine or sherry vinegar, a handful of basil leaves and freshly ground pepper.

Slice the tomatoes and arrange on a platter. Season with salt and let sit 10 minutes. Drizzle with oil and vinegar, scatter with torn basil, grind pepper over and serve with crusty bread to catch the juices. If you wish, add fresh mozzarella or burrata and tear it over the top. Ready in 15 minutes.

Recipe 2: Tomato Salad With Cucumber, Shallot and Herbs

Ingredients for four: 1.5 pounds (700 g) chopped heirloom tomatoes, 1 cucumber, 1 small shallot thinly sliced, 2 tablespoons red wine vinegar, 3 tablespoons olive oil, 1/2 teaspoon salt, and chopped parsley, dill or basil.

Soak sliced shallot in the vinegar for 10 minutes to mellow it. Toss with tomatoes, cucumber, salt and oil. Rest 10 minutes. Add herbs at the end. Serve with grilled bread or fish. See Seasonal Salads That Celebrate Local Harvests for more ideas.

Recipe 3: Heirloom Tomato Tart

Ingredients: 1 sheet puff pastry or a pie dough, 1 cup (115 g) shredded cheese such as Gruyère, 1.5 pounds (700 g) tomato slices, olive oil, thyme, salt and pepper.

Heat the oven to 400°F (200°C). Lay pastry on a baking sheet and prick with a fork, leaving a 1-inch border. Salt the tomato slices on paper towels for 20 minutes and pat dry; this keeps the tart from becoming soggy. Scatter cheese over the pastry, arrange tomatoes in a single layer, drizzle with oil, add thyme and bake 30 to 35 minutes until the pastry is golden and the tomatoes have dried a little. Cool 10 minutes before slicing. Allergen note: contains wheat and dairy. More cheese-pairing ideas are in Recipes That Pair Local Cheese and Produce.

Recipe 4: Fresh Tomato Sauce for Pasta

Ingredients: 2 pounds (900 g) ripe tomatoes, 3 tablespoons olive oil, 3 garlic cloves, salt, basil, 12 ounces (340 g) pasta.

Score a small X on each tomato, blanch in boiling water for 30 seconds, then transfer to cold water and slip off the skins. Chop. Warm the oil and garlic in a pan over medium heat for 1 minute, add tomatoes and 1/2 teaspoon salt, and simmer 15 to 20 minutes until saucy. Toss with al dente pasta and basil. For a no-cook version, combine chopped tomatoes with oil, garlic and salt, let marinate 30 minutes, and toss with hot pasta. See Simple Sauces That Highlight Fresh Produce.

When to Use Heirlooms and When Not To

Heirlooms are best raw or lightly cooked. Long cooking erases subtleties, so for big pots of sauce use meaty paste tomatoes or cosmetic seconds. Cracked or very ripe heirlooms are perfect for sauce, gazpacho and soup because their flaws do not matter once blended.

Ask farmers about "seconds" boxes at lower prices. Using them reduces waste, as discussed in Farm to Table and the Fight Against Food Waste. If you want to preserve a surplus, use only tested recipes. Tomatoes sit near the pH borderline for safe boiling-water canning, and tested recipes require added acid. Do not improvise; consult the National Center for Home Food Preservation for instructions, or freeze tomatoes whole or as sauce instead.

Food Safety and Pairings

Wash tomatoes under running water just before cutting. Keep cut tomatoes refrigerated if not eaten within two hours, though flavor is best at room temperature, so plan to serve soon after cutting. Pairing ideas: fresh cheeses, olive oil, basil, peaches, corn, cucumbers, anchovies, grilled bread, eggs and melon. Acidic tomatoes work well with creamy ingredients; sweet ones pair with sharp vinegar or capers.

Seasonally, make the most of the peak. Cook little, salt well and let the tomato carry the dish. For a larger menu around summer produce, see Cooking With What Is in Season Right Now.

Beyond this guide, FARM.fm's humorous story about a hundred farm-to-table recipes and no time to cook will ring true for any busy cook, while FARM.fm's community garden story will feel familiar to any volunteer.

FAQ

Why are heirloom tomatoes more expensive?

They are often lower-yielding, more fragile and more labor-intensive to pick and pack than commercial varieties, and they are usually grown in small quantities.

Should heirloom tomatoes be refrigerated?

Generally no, since cold harms flavor and texture; keep them on the counter and eat within a few days, refrigerating only fully ripe ones you cannot use right away.

Can I cook heirloom tomatoes in sauce?

Yes, especially cracked or very ripe ones, though long cooking masks their subtle flavors, so save perfect specimens for raw dishes.

Keep learning

Browse all 259 guides →